Tarryall Reservoir is located in the Northern vicinity of South Park. The fish feed year-round on leeches, scuds and small fish. Floating the reservoir is the best way to fish this lake. The lake has excellent vegetation growth and Northern Pike tend to lurk in the luscious weed beds. The Colorado Division of Wildlife encourage all fishermen to keep the Northern Pike they catch.
Though open year round, peak season is mid-May through September. You can access the reservoir via County Road 77, also known as Tarryall Road.